My family recently challenged me to use my Traegar grill to cook up pizzas as I bragged about the wonders of this awesome grill. After a bit of research, I learned I would need a pizza stone to make the best pizza using the Traegar grill. If you want to transform your pellet grill into your own pizza kitchen we’ve got you covered with this compilation of the best pizza stones for Traegar pellet grills.
In a Hurry? The Baking Steel – Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone is our Top Pick for Best Pizza Stone for Traegar grills. The innovative design results in the best pizza I’ve made on my pellet grill.
Quick Comparison of The Best Pizza Stones For Traegar Pellet Grills
| Class | Brand | What We Liked |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall |   Baking Steel - The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone | - Unbreakable - Cooks 20 X faster than traditional pizza stones |
| Great Pizza Stone Alternative |   Lodge BOLD 14 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan | - Large cooking surface - Made in USA |
| Pizza Stone with Handles |   Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone | - Handles high heat well - Dishwasher safe |
| Pizza Stone and Paddle Combo |   Augosta Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill | - Budget-friendly - Heat safe up to 1112 degrees F |
| Pizza Stone with a Rack |   Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack | - Great heat retention - Easy to transport |
| Pizza Stone Kit |   Cuzi Gourmet XL 4-Piece Pizza Stone Set | - Included accessories - Large 15" pizza stone |
Be sure to read through the entire article for detailed information on the above recommendations and additional information on pizza stones.
Should I Use a Pizza Stone on a Pellet Grill
Using a pizza stone on pellet grills allows you to replicate the conditions of a wood-burning pizza oven and will result in a great-tasting pizza!
A good pizza stone will absorb heat well over the entire surface. So, when you place your pizza on the stone the whole crust can begin cooking evenly without any delay in heating.
You should indeed use a pizza stone on a pellet grill if you want to get the light, crisp pizza crust that’s expected on an authentic gourmet pizza.
If you’re a fan of Traegar pellet grills you already know about the versatility to smoke, grill, roast, braise and BBQ using this popular outdoor appliance. Now, with the added ability to make authentic pizzeria-style pizza by using a pizza stone, I’m wondering if I even need a kitchen oven anymore!
Review of the Best Pizza Stones For Traegar Grills
To ensure that you select the best pizza stone for your Traegar smoker/ pellet grill, we have compiled detailed research on some of the best choices.
1. Editor’s Choice: Baking Steel – The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone
This steel “pizza stone” is our top overall pick and we’ll explain exactly why. While it’s not your traditional pizza stone, the innovative design results in the best pizza I’ve made on my Traegar grill.
Cracking or breaking is always a concern with traditional pizza stones. This steel option is not only unbreakable but it also cooks 20 X faster than baking stones. Once the steel “stone” was hot and ready I had a NY style quality pizza in less than 10 minutes!
Because it’s made of steel you can also use it as a stovetop griddle. Also, this is one of the few pizza stones proudly Made in the USA. You’ll have a difficult task finding a better pizza stone option for making pizza on your pellet grill.
Pros
- Unbreakable
- Cooks 20 X faster than traditional pizza stones
- Made in USA
- Results in great, crispy crust
Cons
- Heavy
- Expensive
2. Lodge BOLD 14 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan
The Lodge 14 inch seasoned pan is another popular pizza stone alternative used by many outdoor cooks. The cast iron material construction promises even heating without hotspots at the highest temperatures. This quality is essential to cooking a good pizza on a pellet grill such as a Traegar.
Another great quality is the preseasoned nonstick surface. If a little cheese slips onto the pan you don’t have to work to release your pizza as the pan surface provides an easy release.
I also love the fact that the pan has a slight lip around the edge. This way I don’t have to worry about my pizza or other foods mistakenly sliding off the side.
Pros
- Large cooking surface
- Made in the USA
- Handles make is easy to maneuver
- Great heat retention
Cons
- Takes a while to preheat
3. Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone
The Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone is easily the most unique and stylish pizza stones for the Traegar grill on our round-up. Even better than good looks, is the fact that it’s made of natural ceramic material.
This is a highly durable and scratch resistance pizza stone with handles that make it easy to use and carry. You’ll have no problem using it under the high heat of a pellet grill as it withstands temperatures up to 900 degrees F.
We found this ceramic pizza stone to be very easy to clean and scratch-resistant. The glazed finish of the pizza stone allows your pizza to get a crispy, authentic crust.
Pros
- Ability to cut pizza directly on stone surface
- Handles high heat well
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Can easily break if dropped
4. Augosta Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill
This option for your Traegar pellet grill is great if you want a set that includes a pizza stone and paddle. The pizza stone is made of the traditional pizza stone material Cordierite. With the free, included pizza paddle and the budget-friendly price, this stone is the best bang for your buck.
The material of the pizza stone is 100% all-natural FDA-safe so you won’t have to worry about any harmful toxins. Cleaning of the pizza stone is very easy. Just use warm water and a scrubbing brush once the stone has cooled and you’re done.
If you require a larger sized pizza stone, the brand also has a 16 x 14 inch option that includes a free pizza scraper instead of a pizza board.
Pros
- Budget-friendly
- Heat safe up to 1112 degrees F
- Includes a free pizza peel board
Cons
- Need to flour stone to avoid pizza from sticking
- Small
5. Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack
KEY DETAILS:
- Size: 16.7” with handles / 13.5” without handles
- Material: Cordierite
If you’re looking for the best pizza stone with a rack for Traegar grills this is the one for you. This is a great Cordierite pizza stone from the renowned Weber brand. Cordierite stone material absorbs moisture which lead to a lighter, crispier crust.
The carrying rack makes it easy to safely and quickly transport your pizza. We had no problem making a gourmet pizza on this thick, high-quality stone. The listed diameter of the pizza stone is 14”, however, after measuring it was actually 13.5”.
Even though I purchased this stone for my pellet grill, the design makes it easy for even my teens to use on our Weber kettle grill and the grill over our fire pit. Just be sure to handwash the stone after use to enjoy for years to come.
Pros
- Easy to transport
- Makes light, crispy pizza crusts
- Retains heat very well
Cons
- Usage instructions are unclear
- Small size
6. Cuzi Gourmet XL 4-Piece Pizza Stone Set
KEY DETAILS:
- Size: 22” with handles / 15” without handles
- Material: Cordierite
Are you looking for a ready to go pizza stone kit for yourself or as a gift? We recently came across this highly rated kit by Cuzi Gourmet that comes complete with the following:
- Large 15” Cordierite pizza stone
- Pizza stone rack
- 14” pizza cutter
- Pizza peel/ paddle with 8” handle
The large 15” pizza stone is one of the largest on our list and is great for making authentic, crispy pizzas on your Traegar pellet grill that will be a hit!
Oftentimes, included accessories are merely decorative and non-functional. That’s not the case with this pizza stone kit. The included rack, pizza cutter and paddle are great and saves you the trouble of purchasing each separately.
I would eventually upgrade the pizza peel and cutter as the included ones are made of bamboo which has the tendency to split.
Pros
- Included accessories
- Large 15” pizza stone
- Affordable
Cons
- May need to upgrade accessories
- Thin stone
Best Pellet Grill Pizza Stone Buying Guide
The main features to consider in selecting the best pizza stone for the Traegar grill is relative to your cooking needs.
Do you need to feed a large group? Do you prefer slick, non-stick cooking surfaces? Your answers to these questions will lead you to the first feature to be considered – which is the construction of the pizza stone.
1. Material Construction
This is basically what the pizza stone is made of. Options in terms of our featured pizza stones are Cordierite, Cast Iron, Steel and Ceramic. Let’s examine each one.
Cordierite
When you think of a pizza stone, the picture in your head if probably that of a cordierite stone. This is a popular stone used for cooking pizza as it absorbs moisture well and tolerates high heat. These are both conditions that are needed to obtain a nice, crispy pizza crust.
Since cordierite stone is porous it will absorb oils from the pizza. This isn’t a problem as long as you wash the stone within hours of it cooling off.
If you leave oil and residue on a cordierite stone overnight or for days it may be too late and you’re stone can develop an awful rancid smell. If you know you’re a procrastinator it’s probably best to invest in a different pizza stone material such as cast iron.
Cast Iron
Cast iron pizza stones are masters of heat retention. It’s also extremely durable and won’t crack if exposed to thermal shock. Also, since the surface of the cast iron pizza stone is seasoned your finished pizza will easily release.
It’s also a highly forgiving material. If you’ve had a few beers or want to delay cleaning your cast iron pizza stone for a bit it’s no problem.
Since cast iron doesn’t have pores like cordierite you can delay cleaning until the next day and won’t have to worry about it smelling like rotten eggs during your next pizza cooking.
Steel
Steel pizza stones are excellent for Traegar grills. The steel material is very conductive and stores up to 18 x more energy than traditional pizza stones.
The stored heat rapidly cooks the pizza crust which gives you a pizzeria quality product. I brought my steel pizza stone over to my friend’s to use in their outdoor pizza oven and she was blown away by the awesome results.
I consistently get perfect, crispy crusts when using steel baking stones even at lower temperatures. Did we also mention that steel baking stones for pizza are unbreakable!
Ceramic
Ceramic pizza stones such as the Emile Henry Flame Pizza Stone we profiled earlier gives you one of the best non-stick surfaces. Plus, ceramic pizza stones are glazed which contributes to crispy, well-baked crusts.
Ceramic pizza stones are also the easiest to clean. They are dishwasher safe and can cleaned easily with soap and water.
A downside to ceramic pizza stones is that they can be fragile. If you drop it the chances of it breaking are pretty high. Also, it is highly susceptible to thermal shock.
2. Size
The average pizza stone whether circular or square-shaped will be approximately 14 inches. This is large enough to accommodate a 12 inch pizza which is the size of a medium pizza in restaurants and stores. A 12” pizza is usually enough for a couple of people.
However, someone may want a pizza with different toppings. In this case you may opt for a large rectangular pizza stone which is longer and can be used to cook multiple smaller pizzas at a time. Unicook has a great rectangular 20” long cordierite pizza stone option.
Did You Miss Our Top Pick?
The Baking Steel – Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone is our Top Pick for Best Pizza Stone for Traegar grills. The innovative design results in the best pizza with the lightest, crispiest crust!
Our Final Thoughts
We are happy to have helped you learn more about finding the best pizza stone for Traegar or pellet grills. Remember that if in doubt about the pizza stone that’s best for you to choose one that suits your individual lifestyle, needs and preferences.
You may prefer a cast iron pizza stone. Or maybe you love the benefits of a baking steel pizza stone like me. The great thing is we’ve provided options for all individual preferences. Bon appetit!
Related Articles: